If you're planning a bathroom remodel, one of the biggest decisions you'll make is whether to install a walk-in shower, a bathtub, or both.

The answer depends on your bathroom's layout, your preferences, and how you actually use the space. While there isn't a one-size-fits-all solution, understanding the advantages of each option can help you make a decision you'll be happy with for years to come.

Here's what Bend homeowners should consider when deciding between a walk-in shower and a tub.

Why This Decision Matters

Bathrooms have evolved significantly over the past decade. For example, balancing preferences like accessibility versus a spa experience has changed how we view a bathroom remodel.

Many homeowners are prioritizing:

• Easier maintenance
• Better accessibility
• Spa-like experiences
• Improved functionality

As a result, walk-in showers have become increasingly popular. At the same time, bathtubs continue to play an important role in many households and remain an important feature for families with young children and adults who enjoy a good soak.

The key is choosing the option that best fits your home and lifestyle.

Benefits of a Walk-In Shower

Walk-in showers have become one of the most requested features in bathroom remodels, and it's easy to understand why.

Modern Appearance

A large walk-in shower often creates a more open and contemporary feel. Glass enclosures, large-format tile, and minimal visual barriers can make even small bathrooms feel larger.

Improved Accessibility

Curbless or low-threshold showers are easier to enter and exit, making them a popular option for homeowners planning to age in place or improve accessibility.

Many homeowners view this as an investment in long-term usability as much as aesthetics.

Easier Maintenance

Large soaking tubs often require significant cleaning and maintenance. Walk-in showers generally have fewer surfaces and are easier to keep clean, especially when designed with modern materials and glass treatments.

Better Use of Space

In many homes, removing an oversized tub creates opportunities for:

• Larger showers
• Additional storage
• Double vanities
• Improved layouts

For smaller bathrooms, this can dramatically improve functionality.

Benefits of a Bathtub

Despite the growing popularity of large walk-in showers, tubs still offer several important advantages.

Family-Friendly Functionality

For households with young children, a lack of a bathtub could be a deal-breaker in the search for a new home. Bath time in a permanent tub is simply easier, safer, and more comfortable than trying to manage young kids in a shower. Even if your children eventually outgrow it, having at least one bathtub can make everyday routines much more convenient during those early years.

Many homeowners consider future buyers' needs when making remodeling decisions. If you're replacing a tub in a primary bathroom, remodeling professionals typically recommend keeping a bathtub in a secondary or guest bathroom whenever possible.

Relaxation and Comfort

For many homeowners, a bathtub offers something a shower simply can't: the opportunity to slow down and unwind. After a day skiing at Mt. Bachelor, hiking the Cascades, or simply tackling a busy workweek, a long soak can become part of a daily wellness routine.

Freestanding tubs and deep soaking tubs continue to be popular features in larger primary bathrooms, creating a spa-like retreat that blends comfort, luxury, and relaxation. When space and budget allow, many homeowners enjoy pairing a walk-in shower with a soaking tub to create the best of both worlds.

When a Walk-In Shower Makes the Most Sense

A walk-in shower is often the best choice when:

• The bathroom is smaller
• Accessibility is a priority
• The existing tub is rarely used
• Storage and functionality are more important than bathing
• A more modern appearance is desired

Many homeowners find that they use their shower daily while the bathtub sits untouched.

When a Tub Makes the Most Sense

A bathtub may be the better option when:

• The home currently has no other tub
• Young children regularly use the bathroom
• Relaxation and soaking are important
• The bathroom has sufficient space
• Resale considerations favor maintaining at least one tub

The Best of Both Worlds

For larger primary bathrooms, many homeowners choose both.

A spacious walk-in shower paired with a freestanding tub creates a luxurious, spa-inspired feel while preserving flexibility and functionality.

While this option requires more square footage and budget, it often delivers the greatest versatility.

If you're evaluating investment levels, our guide to Bathroom Remodel Costs in Bend, Oregon can help you understand pricing expectations for different project scopes.

How Cost Impacts the Decision

The cost difference between a shower and tub varies depending on materials, plumbing requirements, and layout changes.

In many cases:

• Standard tubs may be less expensive initially
• Custom walk-in showers often require more tile and labor
• Relocating plumbing increases costs regardless of which option you choose

The overall design and scope of the project typically have a larger impact on cost than the fixture itself.

Which Option Adds More Value?

The answer depends on the home.

Generally speaking:

• A high-quality walk-in shower is often viewed as a premium upgrade.
• Maintaining at least one bathtub somewhere in the home helps preserve broad buyer appeal.
• Functionality and layout improvements usually matter more than choosing one fixture over the other.

The best decision is the one that aligns with how you live today while still making sense for the future.

Planning a Bathroom Remodel in Bend?

Whether you're considering a walk-in shower, a freestanding tub, or a complete bathroom transformation, thoughtful planning helps ensure the finished space fits your lifestyle and goals.

The best bathroom remodels aren't simply about trends—they're about creating a space that functions beautifully every day.

‍